Speaker 0: so meta, facebook's parent company, is facing an antitrust lawsuit related to whatsapp and instagram. what's going on here, john? Speaker 1: yeah. so is this before we dive into it, is this because of the whistleblower? you know? Speaker 0: i don't know if it is because of the ritzle blower, but i think the whistleblower added a bunch more information to it. yeah. i think, you know, the acquisition is under scrutiny because they bought instagram in 02/2012 for a billion dollars and whatsapp in 02/2014 for 19,000,000,000. and they're like, you know, are you cornering the market? is this a thing going on? Speaker 1: yeah. so they said that they were buying whatsapp and instagram for business expansion, but, the government's case is built on internal communications that include emails from ceo mark zuckerberg, which suggests that they're doing a buy or bury approach to the competition. so, they're saying that they did strategic moves to neutralize emerging competitors and cement facebook's dominance in the social mark network networking market. and, apparently, this trial is super technical, and it's focusing on market definition and competitive effects. so they're arguing that meta's control over platforms for sharing content with friends and family constitutes a monopoly. yeah, baby. and that the acquisition stifled innovation, reduced consumer choice, and led to lower privacy standards. so interesting. i could go into a lot more details, but i'd love to get your thoughts on this, craig. Speaker 0: well, the ftc argues for a narrow definition, around personal social networking, suggesting that meta holds a monopolistic power in this specific segment. this definition is crucial to all this because it excludes tiktok, youtube, and x as direct competitors. it focuses on friend and family, connections rather than content discovery. it suggests that meta's faces limited domestic competition beyond, snapchat and meewee, and it frames meta's acquisition as attempt to dominate this specific niche of social networking. so yeah. i have two schools of thought. you know? in the startup world, you know, at y combinator, all the investors, they always say, is this a buyer, barry? is this a builder buy, type of thing? and it's out there, and it's promoted by investors. it's promoted by mentors. it's promoted. so when somebody actually does it, this is a problem? Speaker 1: well, maybe it's it's the way they did it. i don't know. Speaker 0: like so i agree. i i just have to take a step back. and every time, you know, we see this type of stuff, we have to say, okay. you know, with the google chrome, with whatever, like, are these truly anti competitive, tory, or, you know, is it something else? so i'm always curious when we see these things. as, you know, more social networks emerge and, you know, we're openai seems like they're building their own in the background. there's many stories around that happening now. so the question is why is it, your relationship connections? it's the network that they're tracking that's the problem. who's in your group on snap on, whatsapp that you're chatting with and who's in your group on, facebook that you're talking to and who are you connected to and all that stuff. so i guess it's that social graph piece, on facebook that's the problem. Speaker 1: yeah. yeah. so this is interesting because they might set a new regulatory precedent if they win because the case is testing whether us antitrust law can retroactively challenge mergers that were previously approved based on their long term competitive effects. so if they do win, which it's this is gonna be a tough one, because of the precedent that it's gonna set. but if they do win, then no mergers is ever safe, i guess. Speaker 0: yeah. and so it's you know, the company's email suggests that meta prioritize buying potential competitors rather than competing through innovation. Speaker 1: yeah. Speaker 0: build or buy. those are decisions that are made all the time. and now if there's an email or some recording that says, should we build this or just buy somebody who does this well and add it to our portfolio, and all of a sudden that becomes anti competitive? or is it actually anti competitive? like, this is why these things are a little vague when we read through them, and it makes me skeptical because is this wild government overreach or are this big corporation screwing us? i wanna know which one it is. Speaker 1: yeah. well, i do know that meta's data privacy policies are absolutely horrific. they're one of the worst i've ever read. so i see that. but yeah. so there is i don't know. there is competition, though, because like you said, there's tiktok, there's youtube, there's, and youtube's very popular. so i don't know. i i don't know how but here's the thing that i, like, if there is internal communication that comes out as to the actual reason for buying it, and that is that shows that it's more to monopolize than to just expand, then, yes, go after them. 100%. because then you lied. right? then you lied about your intent. Speaker 0: i guess. i mean, it depends. i guess, as far as i'm concerned, i don't know. like, did they have to file a whole bunch of stuff with the government and then lie about what they were doing? and if that's the case, then, yeah, def definitely. they're just telling somebody saying, hey. we're doing it because of these things. and, you know, those are only three minor things. there's actually three major things because people do things for all sorts of reasons. so, you know, with x trying to create everything app and them going after whatsapp and trying to buy the market, it seemed like a natural thing. however, natural, could be anti competitive when we're saying, you know, facebook and meta, you're big enough already. stop taking more chunk of the pie away from everyone else. it feels like a socialistic move rather than a capitalistic move. Speaker 1: yeah. Speaker 0: so i'm just curious as from the stuff i've seen here, is it the hidden information that they're dealing with that no one else has that's the problem? and and that you know, all our internal relationships? and so what are they saying the answer is? that they want to open up our internal relationships to everyone else, or facebook's gotta stop tracking it? Speaker 1: yeah. i don't. i don't think so. it's, like, from what i read, i think it's more of the intent, of the purchases. that's what i'm getting from it, but i could be wrong, though. Speaker 0: so the case pro's fundamental questions about what constitutes healthy, competitive competition social media markets and how dynamically evolving platforms should be evaluated under antitrust frameworks. meta's defense emphasizes that rapidly changing nature of digital competition where new answers like tiktok can quickly capture massive user engagement, where user preferences continually evolve, this, perspective suggests that temporary market leadership should not be confused with durable monopolistic power. so the court's determination will influence how companies approach acquisitions of emerging competitors, whether platforms emphasize differentiation or integration, investment patterns in social media startups, and the evolution of content discovery versus, social connection features. so we'll have to see, what they do. Speaker 1: yeah. well, we'll definitely track this one. this one's interesting. so, i like that i have to say, i do like that the ftc, and i said this before, is growing some and, and challenging some things now. right? whereas before, it was just status quo. people could do whatever they want. but who knows where this goes? Speaker 0: regardless of the outcome, this case represents a pivotal moment in the evolution of a digital platform regulation. several potential scenarios could unfold. complete divestiture of both instagram and whatsapp, creating new independent competitors in the social media landscape. partial remedies that maintain ownership but require operational separation and reduce sharing between platforms. behavioral remedies that impose ongoing restrictions on meta's business practices without structural changes, and, a ruling favoring meta that maintains the status quo but potentially includes some operational constraints could, you know, trigger different things. so we'd love to hear what you think is gonna happen with this court case. and with meta's market capitalization approaching $3,300,000,000,000, the stakes extend far beyond the company itself. so i'd love to hear what your thoughts are on the future of whatsapp, instagram, and meta.